Tuesday, March 1, 2016

To Clean and Repair or Not

              

W

hat many collectors of especially antique cars, bronze statues, many forms of lamps, and vintage/antique stuffed animals and dolls look for and desire is patina. This oxidization is a natural process of aging for say a bronze statue. It is valued and prized by many collectors, and should not be cleaned. As an example, the Statue of Liberty has a rich green patina that has occurred over the years. Nobody would suggest cleaning it up by removing the rich green patina created by the oxidization of the bronze. This adds to the character of the statue and is not considered dirt. Patina for items like stuffed animals and dolls would be natural wear and tear (some would call this the love a child has by hugging and playing with the stuffed animal or doll) – for example loss of some of the hair or fur.

 
T

hen there is cleaning. Cleaning is designed and intended to remove dirt and oils – both being undesirable. Many oils have corrosive elements that can be destructive with whatever they come in contact with. For example, touching and handling stuffed animals with oily hands will leave that oil on the fur of the stuffed animal. Over time, you will notice the corrosive elements at work, slowly eroding away the fur and stuffing. Then there is dirt. Not only does dirt make an item look dingy and less bright, it can also act like sandpaper, slowing grinding away at an item. One way to alleviate (though not eliminate) this is to wash hands thoroughly before touching items susceptible to deterioration from oils and dirt. Another option, especially for the older more rare items is to wear clean white cotton gloves while handling these items.

On occasion, these items should be cleaned. Some items can be easily cleans at home using a very weak solution of water and gentle dish detergent.  Other times – depending on the degree of dirt or complexity of the cleaning an item – you need to have it professionally cleaned.  

Why cleaning almost all vintage collectibles - is so important.  There are four main reasons. 

First, obviously, is appearance.  Dirty items simply look worse and less cared for than clean ones. 

Second is structural integrity and longevity.  Dirt and dust are not good and can weaken the materials over time, possibly decreasing the item's lifespan. 

Third, with some items dirt can also attract moths and other bug pests, and everyone knows the havoc and sometimes irreversible damage these insect pests can create. 

And finally, when you bring a vintage item into your collection, you really don't know most of the time the conditions in which it was loved, kept, or displayed in any of its previous lives - or what might be hidden in the item. It is never a bad idea to thoroughly clean a vintage item before introducing it to the rest of your collection.
 

T

he second part of this article addresses repairs and restoration. Opinion is divided on this depending on who you talk with. There are plenty of businesses out there in the repair and restoration field that have their own take on the issue. Bear in mind that their job is to sell their product and service. To some degree the approach depends on the category of collectibles. There are three schools of thought regarding repair that I am aware of:

S

chool of thought number one is do no repairs. This train of thought says that repairs will negatively alter the value of the collectible. Collectibles should be appreciated for the wear and tear they show. I know of a person who has two Steiff Zotty Bears. The smaller of the two was fine, but badly needed some cleaning from years of play and love. After his bath, he looked like a new man – er? – bear. The larger of the two not only needed to be cleaned, but had a sizeable tear around the neck area. It is believed that the Zotty Bear was attacked by the pet dog when the owner was a child. A poor attempt at stitching the Zotty Bear was made at the time, but it was VERY poor attempt. After consultation with a teddy bear/Steiff repair specialist, the end result was that now not only is he a very clean bear, you are not able to tell that there were any repairs made at all. It is safe to say that not only has the life of the Zotty Bear been dramatically increased (the repairs prevented Zotty Bear’s wounds from getting worse and ripping open even more), he looks better and plays better.

T

his dovetails into the second school of thought. Repairs should be made to restore the collectible. Material and processing technology typical of the time period the piece was originally manufactured should be used to make repairs. The above Zotty Bear story perfectly illustrates school of thought number two. This will increase the life of the piece should you want to keep it, and also the fair market value should you want to sell it.

 
R

estoring a ’57 Chevy to something other than the original factory specifications would epitomize school of thought number 3. This would mean putting in an engine from another entirely car or even from a different manufacture. I have seen a Mercedes Benz “SL” outfitted with a Chevrolet engine. Another example would be adding modern day dashboard electronics not yet invented when your car was originally manufactured, leave alone not original to your restoration vehicle. Another example is using modern day car paint on restoring a car 75 years old. This school of thought is fine if you plan on keeping the car. However, if you plan on selling the car, you may find difficulty in selling it for anything close to what you invested in it. Your taste in restoration may not match up very well with what is out there in the market – be it the car market or any other market.

F

or another real life application on whether to restore a Teddy Bear or not, please read ” To Restore Or Not To Restore, That's The Steiff Question” for one author’s take on the question. For a third source on the issue, please see the 28 February 2016 airing of “60 Minutes”, “Preserving the Past”.

Harald Mallwitz

Coppell Collectibles, L.L.C.

Coppell, TX

A Teddy bear does not come to life until he is loved, but once loved he will live forever

http://coppellcollectibles.blogspot.com/